Content pirates ordered to pay $29M in damages to Bell, Rogers, TVA

A Federal Court judge has ordered three pirate TV providers to pay more than $29 million in damages to Bell, Rogers and TVA, who submitted that pre-loaded set-top boxes and internet protocol television (IPTV) have been undercutting paid access to their content.

The defendants, INL3D, Morcor, Ottawa Tek and its sole director, Raheel Rafiq, were found to have deliberately encouraged consumers to bypass legitimate ways of accessing content by promoting free access to hundreds of programs.

Granting a permanent injunction against the defendants, the judgement awards the broadcasters statutory damages in the amount of $29,300,000, as well as punitive damages in the amount of $300,000 and a lump-sum amount of $75,000 for costs.

The plaintiffs acknowledged that while difficult to quantify the impact on their respective businesses directly attributable to the defendants’ activities, they asserted that content piracy has led to changes in consumer behaviour and, hence, significant negative financial consequences for content owners and distributors. They pointed to CRTC estimates that, between 2015 and 2018, subscriptions to television services in Canada declined by about 518,000 (an average rate of decline of about 1.14%), with a resultant decrease in annual revenues of about $528 million (1.48% annually). Specialty and pay television services have seen average percentage declines double that.

In a release welcoming the ruling, Bell estimated the negative financial impact of TV piracy on Canadian broadcasters and distributors is in the range of $500 million to $650 million per year. It also asserts an estimated one in three piracy websites contain malware that put personal information and other data on shared networks and devices at risk.

Wade Oosterman, President Bell Media and Vice Chair, BCE and Bell, said the judgment sends a clear signal that those engaged in content piracy will face stiff legal repercussions.

“Bell invests hundreds of millions of dollars every year to develop, produce, acquire and deliver great Canadian and international content over multiple platforms, but content piracy continues to undermine the entire media industry, including the work of many Canadians,” said Oosterman. “By imposing stiff financial penalties on companies that enable and promote unauthorized access to content online and via set-top box add-ons, the Federal Court has sent a clear message.”

Bell is in favour of additional measures from the CRTC and federal government to curb content piracy, including facilitating the removal of pirated content from online platforms and disabling access to sites distributing illegal content.


Subscribe Now – Free!

Broadcast Dialogue has been required reading in the Canadian broadcast media for 25 years. When you subscribe, you join a community of connected professionals from media and broadcast related sectors from across the country.

The Weekly Briefing from Broadcast Dialogue is delivered exclusively to subscribers by email every Thursday. It’s your link to critical industry news, timely people moves, and excellent career advancement opportunities.

Let’s get started right now.

* indicates required