HomeCanadian PerspectivesOP-ED: The CRTC's Music Database -...

OP-ED: The CRTC’s Music Database – A Good Beginning, but a Bigger Opportunity

Andrew ForsythIn 2022, the CRTC outlined an ambitious and welcome initiative: the development of a centralized music database that would simplify the identification of Canadian musical selections, improve the accuracy of information available to broadcasters and reduce the risk of regulatory non-compliance.

Four years later, the Commission has introduced the first version of that database.

It is an important step forward. But an examination of its contents suggests there is still considerable work to be done before it can fulfill the role the Commission originally envisioned.

The opportunity is substantial. A comprehensive, reliable database could become one of the most useful regulatory resources available to Canadian broadcasters.

The question is whether it will become more than a catalogue of recordings.

Identifying a recording is not the same as qualifying it

The Commission has built its database around internationally recognized music identification standards, including the International Standard Recording Code (ISRC).

These identifiers are essential to the modern music industry. They help distinguish recordings, compositions and their associated rights.

But an ISRC does not determine whether a recording qualifies as Canadian Content under the CRTC’s MAPL regulations.

That determination requires additional information about the performers, composers, lyricists, performance and, in certain circumstances, historical regulatory provisions.

Our examination of the initial database identified 19,687 ISRC-coded records representing just 1,708 unique artist/title combinations.

The distinction is important. Thousands of recording identifiers do not necessarily represent thousands of different musical selections.

More concerning is what we discovered when examining Canadian Content classifications.

Of 256 artist/title combinations identified as non-Canadian, our historical research found 230 that had previously been recognized as Canadian Content through published MAPL designations, record-company documentation and, in some instances, CRTC staff reviews.

These discrepancies deserve careful reconciliation.

They include recordings by contemporary Canadian artists such as Drake, Avril Lavigne, The Weeknd and Brett Kissel, as well as recordings whose qualifications date back decades.

This is not simply an argument about old records. It is about preserving confidence in the regulatory classifications that broadcasters have relied upon for more than half a century.

When yesterday’s Canadian Content becomes today’s question mark

Consider The Archies’ 1969 recording of Sugar, Sugar, co-written by Canadian Andy Kim and American Jeff Barry.

Ted Kennedy’s Canadian chart research publication, Maple Music, documents the recording’s appearance on the RPM charts, identifying its Canadian Content qualification under the L (Lyrics) component of MAPL. The recording reached No. 1 on Sept. 13, 1969, remaining there for three weeks, spending seven weeks in the Top 10 and 11 weeks in the Top 40.

That historical documentation is significant. Recordings made before January 1972 may qualify under provisions requiring only one Canadian MAPL component.

The Commission has previously recognized the importance of preserving legitimate historical Canadian Content qualifications.

Introducing modern recording identifiers should not inadvertently invalidate those established classifications. Nor should broadcasters be expected to reconstruct decades of historical documentation simply to confirm the eligibility of selections long accepted in their music libraries.

The database should provide that confidence. It should also explain why a recording qualifies.

A simple “Yes” or “No” designation offers little assistance when the underlying information is incomplete or a classification is disputed.

The MAPL components, relevant creative contributors and applicable historical provisions should be available to users.

The database needs to reflect the regulations

Other elements of the database warrant attention.

Original release dates matter, particularly for recordings subject to historical Canadian Content provisions. A remastered recording released digitally decades later should not lose its original history.

Recording duration matters because the Radio Regulations, 1986 explicitly reference musical selections broadcast in their entirety for specified Canadian Content and French-language music requirements.

Musical subcategories matter because the classification of an individual recording may differ from the general reputation of the artist performing it.

These are not merely programming conveniences. They are information requirements that can directly affect regulatory compliance.

But perhaps the greatest opportunity lies beyond conventional Canadian Content identification.

Four classifications, one common resource

The Commission’s regulatory framework requires broadcasters to consider several distinct musical qualifications.

Canadian Content is one. French-language vocal music (FVM) is another.

French-language broadcasters must satisfy requirements for French-language vocal selections, including recordings by artists who are not Canadian.

The Commission itself acknowledged in 2022 that identifying French-language vocal music through automated systems presents challenges. Its definition relies on more than 50% of the duration of a selection’s vocal portion being in French.

Four years later, a comprehensive database should be moving toward addressing that challenge. 

Emerging Canadian artists represent a third important classification.

Unlike conventional Canadian Content, emerging artist eligibility is not necessarily permanent. The current version of the database does not flag this requirement.

An artist may qualify during one period of their career and cease to qualify later.

Broadcasters therefore require more than a current Yes or No designation. They need to know when an artist qualified and whether that status applied on the date a recording was broadcast.

Indigenous musical selections represent a fourth essential classification. This is not recognized in the current database.

As Indigenous music exposure becomes part of broadcasters’ regulatory responsibilities, reliable identification of qualifying selections is increasingly important.

These classifications cannot simply be assumed from international recording metadata.

Each requires an appropriate verification process, and Indigenous music identification should be developed with meaningful participation from Indigenous artists and music organizations.

Together, these four areas offer an opportunity to build a common regulatory reference resource serving English-language, French-language, Indigenous and specialty music broadcasters.

Modernization should work both ways

There is another reason this matters.

In its 2025 modernization of radio processes, the Commission emphasized reducing regulatory burden, simplifying administrative requirements and improving compliance procedures.

Those are worthwhile objectives.

Yet broadcasters are still being asked to report the number and percentage of musical selections aired by Emerging Canadian Artists and Indigenous artists without corresponding classifications being available in the Commission’s database.

In practical terms, licensees must independently research and verify information that could be maintained centrally.

This creates unnecessary duplication and increases the possibility of inconsistent reporting as well as resources expended at the cost of other programming initiatives.

A modern regulatory system should not simply make it easier for the Commission to request information. It should also make it easier for broadcasters to obtain and verify the information they are required to provide.

That is where a comprehensive database could make a meaningful difference.

A shared, authoritative resource would reduce administrative effort, improve consistency and give both the regulator and the regulated greater confidence in the information being reported.

Looking forward

The CRTC deserves recognition for undertaking this initiative.

Building a comprehensive music database is no small exercise, particularly when it must reconcile decades of Canadian Content regulations with contemporary international identification standards.

The initial database provides a foundation. Its next stage should concentrate on accuracy, transparency, historical continuity and the practical regulatory requirements of broadcasters.

There is also an important consideration on the horizon.

The Commission’s Path Forward proceedings may result in revised Canadian Content definitions, potentially modifying or replacing elements of the longstanding MAPL framework.

Any resulting changes will require corresponding updates to the database.

That makes flexibility and ongoing maintenance essential considerations today.

The Commission has an opportunity to create more than an inventory of Canadian recordings.

It can establish a common regulatory resource that evolves with its policies, reduces uncertainty and helps broadcasters meet the very obligations the Commission establishes.

A successful music database should not simply tell broadcasters and regulators what a recording is. It should help them understand what it qualifies for, why it qualifies and, where necessary, when that qualification applies.

That would be a meaningful contribution to regulatory modernization.

And a very worthwhile return on the Commission’s investment.

Andrew Forsyth
Andrew Forsyth
Andrew Forsyth is a Canadian broadcasting veteran with more than 50 years of experience in strategic planning, regulatory affairs and industry research. Founder of Forsyth Consulting, he has guided radio station launches, led national research initiatives for the CBC, SOCAN, CAB and CRTC, and successfully represented broadcasters in regulatory proceedings. A former BDSradio/Nielsen/Luminate executive and tenured professor with Seneca@York U, he serves as a Director of the Ontario Association of Broadcasters.

SUBSCRIBE NOW - IT'S FREE!

At Broadcast Dialogue®, we are committed to delivering industry-leading insights, news, and analysis directly to your inbox—completely free of charge.

By providing full / accurate information, you are helping us sustain Broadcast Dialogue® as a free resource. In return, we commit to delivering high-quality content that keeps you informed on the latest trends, technology, and news shaping the broadcast landscape—at no cost to you.

The Weekly Briefing from Broadcast Dialogue® is delivered exclusively to our subscribers by email every Thursday.
Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Your Subscription Information

Your Name
Your Email Address
Broadcast Dialogue uses this information to understand our audience and deliver relevant content.
Broadcast Dialogue uses this information to understand our audience and deliver relevant content.

Your Company Information

A Couple Of Questions

Do you consider yourself retired?
Are you seeking employment opportunities?

Broadcast Dialogue uses this information to understand our audience and deliver relevant content.

Latest News

Longtime K-97 Edmonton radio host Rob Berg passes away

Longtime K-97 (CIRK-FM) Edmonton personality Rob Berg has passed away, the station announced Tuesday. "Today we are celebrating the incredible 30-year legacy of our dear...

2026 Grey Cup draws average audience of four million viewers

Bell Media says Sunday's Grey Cup attracted an average audience of 4 million viewers across TSN, CTV, RDS, and Crave, down slightly from last year's...

Media Sales Manager

Blackburn Media Sarnia is looking for a strategic, motivated, and results-driven Media Sales Manager to lead our sales team. This is a key leadership...

OP-ED: Ottawa Is Regulating Links While The Internet Is Moving to...

The internet did not arrive as a single event. It arrived as a series of small, dismissible changes. Classifieds moved. Then audiences. Then the...

The Weekly Briefing

REVOLVING DOOR: Fred Jacobs, President of Jacobs Media, has announced he’ll be stepping down at the end of the year, ending a 43-year run leading...